Back to the main page

Mailing List Logs for ShadowRN

From: Phillip G Jaros <phillip_jaros@**.US.SWISSBANK.COM>
Subject: Re: RBT, the TPB
Date: Thu, 2 Oct 1997 23:07:40 CDT
>I was just looking at my SRCARD e-mail folder. It's getting pretty
>full _1077 messages_ to date & that's just since the 9th of September
>(when I subscribed). And the majority of these messages seem to
>represnet rules qualifications (and a great number of these are devoted
>to GAQS & NERPS...). Apparently the accompanying 70+ page SRTCG RBT is
>woefully insufficient. Betcha FASA never dreamed of *these* headaches
>when they first planned this TCG!

Woefully insufficient? Hardly. I have yet to read a CCG rulebook that
answered all of the possible card uses. Just about every good CCG has
a rather long list of card errata and FAQs, because:

1. The people that play them really care about the game.
2. People are actually playing the game to find some interesting
situations / confusing card combinations.
3. Play testers probably didn't read the rulebook to learn how to play
because they were taught by the designers. When the rulebook is
finally written, they already understand the rules so it seems like
everything is covered.

> Perhaps Skuzzy & company should now seriously look into publishing a
>full-sized paperback volume, ala WOTC's "Pocket Players Guide to Magic
>the Gathering."). I actually still have my copy of this work (even tho
>I traded in all o' my MTG cards for a bunch of Deadpool comics...).

If it was well made it would be nice, since having a bound version of
the errata and FAQs are always useful.

> Or better still, get FASA/ROC to put out a glossy, Graphic-Novel sized
>TOME with full-colored descriptions & illustrations, along with detailed
>examples of play & deck-building strategies & contests & ...
>
> Yea, that's it. Sure we'd all rush out & buy it, right folks? ;-)

Well I would...

--
Phil Jaros 888888888 Chicago Tech Support
jarosph@**.us.swissbank.com O=O=O=O=O SBC Warburg Dillon Read
___________aaaaaaaaaaaaa___________
___...aaaad8888888888888888p"""""q8888888888888888baaaa...___
``"""""q8888888888888|
|8888888888888p"""""''
``"""""< `=-~-='
>"""""''
Chakan `| ^ |'
The Forever Man / | =-= | \
/ `__.__' \

Disclaimer

These messages were posted a long time ago on a mailing list far, far away. The copyright to their contents probably lies with the original authors of the individual messages, but since they were published in an electronic forum that anyone could subscribe to, and the logs were available to subscribers and most likely non-subscribers as well, it's felt that re-publishing them here is a kind of public service.