| From: | "(Ryan Smith)" <SnakeIzBac@***.COM> |
|---|---|
| Subject: | Re: Deck and card posting replies - or not |
| Date: | Fri, 17 Jul 1998 15:24:55 EDT |
<< Several people were annoyed that nobody or too few people responded to
their deck postings and card ideas.
>From my experience I must say that it is very difficult to give an
accurate criticism of a deck without having played it; few mistakes in a
deck concept jump out at a mere reading. I try to play posted decks when
the opportunity arises, and then I give my comment from actual game
experience. This might take one or the other week.
I´ve seen a lot of fictional card postings recently (duh!), which isn´t
bad at all as such. I´m just getting weary trying to read, analyze, and
criticise seemingly dozens of card ideas every evening. I´ve caught
myself skipping card idea posts recently, but I can´t think of a better
way to organize these messages. Perhaps someone can help me there.Honestly
said, it discourages me a little to think of so many good and/or
creative ideas disappearing in some dark corner of a storage bank.
On the other hand, brainstorming and discussion and vastly too many
ideas are needed to make a good SRTCG expansion. I´m carrying the idea
to compile a Germany or Europe expansion myself, and several friends
have agreed to contribute to this, but I will wait until the Amerindian
expansion goes into its final stages to start posting that one.
>>
Felix I can't agree with you anymore. yes, I too find it difficult rating and
critiquing someone's deck. It's really tough trying to read all of these
cards. There are a lot of bright ideas here, but i admit myself i don't read
everything here.
