Back to the main page

Mailing List Logs for ShadowRN

Message no. 1
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Elves and Humans
Date: Sat, 19 Sep 1998 13:31:34 -0500
----------
> From: Gurth <gurth@******.NL>
> >
> > For now. I think its going to come as a shock to most of the world
once
> > the first elf dies of old age (some 300 years down the line...
>
> Yes, but that still only makes them humans with pointed ears and an
> exceptionally long lifespan. What I really meant was that your average
> typical elf in SR _behaves_ just like humans do -- they want a well-paid
> job, a nice house, a family, and all that other crap everyone else
wants.
> They don't dance around the woods playing harps and shooting arrows at
> intruders. They also don't all go around seeing themselves as the
bestest
> race on the planet.

True, but look at it this way. Imagine that you matured later than
everyone else. I'm talking like, maybe close to five years later. You
don't get your growth spurt until your senior year in high school, you
voice is still a child's. Let's say you marry your High school sweetheart
(a human girl named... Fayette Myers, now Voigt) anyway, get a well-paid
job, a nice house, a family, and manage to almost keep up with the
Joneses. At your tenth wedding anniversary, she's starting to sag a
bit... not much, but its still kinda noticeable, and turning out the
lights doesn't help much. At your 20th anniversary, she's settling into
middle age, and you still look like you did in high school. By your
fiftieth anniversary, she looks her age... and you look yours, if you
count the fact that you're an elf. Two of your kids, the ones who wound
up with smooth ears, look older than you do. Your eldest son is bald, and
your youngest son is getting there. Your daughter, in her mid-forties,
still looks like a Vogue model... and she will, 5 years later when you
bury your wife, tears running down your still un-lined face.
You spend some time in mourning, and there are mornings where you just
don't want to get out of bed because you miss her so much its killing you,
but you slowly get back on your feet, and over time the holo of her in
your wallet gets more and more yellowed. Your great-grandkids are
starting to look older than you now, and you catch yourself looking at
some of their girlfriends... and even more amazing, that they're looking
back. At you, and you're close to a hundred! You start trying to live
your life again, slowly returning to the singles scene, chopping a few
years off your age so you don't scare off the young humans, but letting
the elves know your real age... and dropping hints about the value of
experience. Your daughter has finally given you a grandchild at 75, and
you use him...and your great-great-grandchildren... as a babe-magnet. You
marry again, a pretty young human who you just find yourself unable to say
no to. Sure, you're a century older than her, but what's the saying?
"Young at heart"? Again, though, you find its Fayette all over again...
she grows old, slower, this time, because of increases in technology, but
she grows old... and you now look thirty. Your children come, your
grandchildren, along with great-to the umpteenth-grandchildren from your
first marriage, and you're slowly approaching looking... 35. By the time
your second wife dies, you actually look forty, but you don't feel any
older than when you graduated, nearly 200 years ago.

I'm not saying that elves are suddenly going to start acting like they
live forever next week. I'm saying that when that once you've buried
children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren, you're going to start
withdrawing a bit from humans, to keep yourself safe. The first elves
(discounting spike babies), came along in what, 2020-something, right?
They likely grew up amongst humans, married humans, and are starting to
see their spouses and friends from when they were young deteriorate before
their still young eyes.

> (That's IMHO where most fantasy RPGs become unrealistic -- every member
of
> a given race tends to behave in much the same way, whereas IRL where
> cultures meet you end up with a mix of thoe cultures.)

That is rather unrealistic, true, but I think part of it has to do with
varying life-spans and obvious physical differences. To use AD&D as an
example, humans and halflings have amazingly similar cultures. Why?
Because they interact a lot, look quite a bit alike (except for height,
though a tall halfling and a short human can be pretty close), and live
about the same length. Their "elders" are maybe going to be five to ten
years older than the humans, but its not going to make that much of an
impact.
Dwarves, on the other hand, find whiskers on women attractive, and live
about 5 times as long as humans, and already had a different culture base
to work from. Since their elders are still around to remind them of the
"old ways", you see less divergence from the norm. True, there will be
dwarves who mix human and dwarven culture, but those will always be the
fringe, and in the minority, simply because the first 40 years of a
dwarf's life will be spent amongst dwarves, learning to do things the
traditional dwarven way, which is unchanged because those same elders
won't let it change.

> > to put that
> > in perspective, that's longer than there has been a USA, and only a
few
> > decades less than we've had a settlement at Jamestown).
>
> So? I would be able see a 14th-century church from my window if those
> houses weren't in the way... :)

That is because you're a goddamned furriner with yer corruptin' Yourapeen
ways ::spits:: ;-)

> Unconsciousness is no excuse.

How about semi-consciousness with a twist of delusional paranoia?

Nexx
Message no. 2
From: K in the Shadows <Ereskanti@***.COM>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 01:07:54 EDT
I snipped the entire concept of "Elf marries Human High School Sweetheart."

Nexx, that was really good. Nice view on the game cosmology as well. I like
it. I also like the fact that someone else has noticed this potential concept
as well.

Anyone else play a game that is based further into the future than we have?
The farthest forward we've ever played was 2117. Totally nutso, but kind of
neat in other ways. Nexx's story-concept is just one of them.

-K (applauds)
Message no. 3
From: "D. Ghost" <dghost@****.COM>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 00:17:40 -0500
On Sun, 20 Sep 1998 01:07:54 EDT K in the Shadows <Ereskanti@***.COM>
writes:
>I snipped the entire concept of "Elf marries Human High School
Sweetheart."
>
>Nexx, that was really good. Nice view on the game cosmology as well. I
like
>it. I also like the fact that someone else has noticed this potential
concept
>as well.

Yes, bravo Nexx :)

>Anyone else play a game that is based further into the future than we
have?
>The farthest forward we've ever played was 2117. Totally nutso, but
kind of
>neat in other ways. Nexx's story-concept is just one of them.

Not I. However, when I played RM/RMSS, any elvin character I had only
had relationships with elves or other beings with similar
(artifical/natural) lifespans ...

I take this into account when I am making characters for SR even though I
doubt that we'll be playing long enough for this to come into effect. My
Rigger character is an Ork whois starting the the game at an age of 27...
she doesn't exactly have a lot of time left ... My other characters are 2
elves and a dwarf and so don't have to worry about that ...

--
D. Ghost
(aka Pixel, Tantrum, RuPixel)
o/` I traded my Flesh for a Fantasy and now my truck broke down, my wife
left me, and my dog died o/` -- Billy Idol, Jr. Rock Country Singer

_____________________________________________________________________
You don't need to buy Internet access to use free Internet e-mail.
Get completely free e-mail from Juno at http://www.juno.com
Or call Juno at (800) 654-JUNO [654-5866]
Message no. 4
From: Chris Maxfield <cmaxfiel@****.ORG.AU>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 16:56:30 +1000
At 13:31 19/09/98 -0500, Nexx wrote:
<<<snip>>>
> I'm not saying that elves are suddenly going to start acting like
they
>live forever next week. I'm saying that when that once you've buried
>children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren, you're going to start
>withdrawing a bit from humans, to keep yourself safe. The first elves
>(discounting spike babies), came along in what, 2020-something, right?
>They likely grew up amongst humans, married humans, and are starting to
>see their spouses and friends from when they were young deteriorate before
>their still young eyes.
<<<snip>>>

Excellent! One the best explanations of how it feels to be near immortal
that I've seen in a long time. It's also why I despise those books with
immortal characters that look, act and feel like any average mortal human.




Chris Maxfield
<cmaxfiel@****.org.au>
------------------------------------------
"Every passing hour brings the Solar System forty-three thousand
miles closer to Globular Cluster M13 in Hercules---and still there
are some misfits who insist there is no such thing as progress."
- Kurt Vonnegut, The Sirens of Titan
----------------------------------------
Canberra, Australia
Message no. 5
From: Drea O'Dare <dreaodare@*******.COM>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 00:27:27 PDT
>Excellent! One the best explanations of how it feels to be near
immortal
>that I've seen in a long time. It's also why I despise those books with
>immortal characters that look, act and feel like any average mortal
human.

You too, eh? I dislike greatly anyone that can play an elf that's
been around for any amount of time like they're actually in their 20s
just because they look it. I encourage people not to play them as a
first character, since it takes a little experience to really get it
right (not even taking in that they're supposedly rare as well). I play
two different elf characters, both Spike Babies, both having dealt with
grief and seeing people around them die.
One even has kids - and tends to favor the elfen one, as she knows
that it will live longer. Cold, maybe, but in the royal scheme of
things, I think appropriette.

Pink`

______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
Message no. 6
From: Gurth <gurth@******.NL>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 12:28:29 +0200
According to Nexx, at 13:31 on 19 Sep 98, the word on the street was...

> True, but look at it this way. Imagine that you matured later than
> everyone else. I'm talking like, maybe close to five years later. You
> don't get your growth spurt until your senior year in high school, you
> voice is still a child's.

Are you talking about elves now? In that case, sorry, but they mature just
as quickly as humans, until they're about 20, and then growth (and aging)
seems to stop. I don't remember where this is from, but AFAIK I read it in
a FASA-published SR book (or maybe a novel, but I don't think so).

> Let's say you marry your High school sweetheart
> (a human girl named... Fayette Myers, now Voigt)

Nice reference :)

[snip rest]

That stil doesn't convince me -- all you're saying is that they live a lot
longer and would go through about the same thing you see in the first
Highlander movie. I don't really see how that should affect the way elves
behave in SR (because the oldest elf is 49 years old in 2060, discounting
spike babies of course), and certainly not how it relates to the "elven
culture" idea so many _players_ seem to insist on caryring over from other
games. (Even FASA with their "Elven Wines" skill -- why would elves have
special kinds of wines? Now if that skill were called "Tir Tairngire
Wines" I could buy it...)

> > Unconsciousness is no excuse.
>
> How about semi-consciousness with a twist of delusional paranoia?

That is :)

--
Gurth@******.nl - http://www.xs4all.nl/~gurth/index.html
Unconsciousness is no excuse.
-> NERPS Project Leader * ShadowRN GridSec * Unofficial Shadowrun Guru <-
-> The Plastic Warriors Page: http://www.xs4all.nl/~gurth/plastic.html <-
-> The New Character Mortuary: http://www.electricferret.com/mortuary/ <-

GC3.1: GAT/! d-(dpu) s:- !a>? C+(++)@ U P L E? W(++) N o? K- w+ O V? PS+
PE Y PGP- t(+) 5++ X++ R+++>$ tv+(++) b++@ DI? D+ G(++) e h! !r(---) y?
Incubated into the First Church of the Sqooshy Ball, 21-05-1998
Message no. 7
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 09:18:49 -0500
----------
> From: K in the Shadows <Ereskanti@***.COM>
>
> I snipped the entire concept of "Elf marries Human High School
Sweetheart."
>
> Nexx, that was really good. Nice view on the game cosmology as well. I
like
> it. I also like the fact that someone else has noticed this potential
concept
> as well.

Thank you. Did anyone get where I stole the names from?

Nexx, who hasn't changed his nickname yet because he can't think of a good
one.
Message no. 8
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 09:21:08 -0500
----------
> From: D. Ghost <dghost@****.COM>
>
> >Nexx, that was really good. Nice view on the game cosmology as well.
I
> like
> >it. I also like the fact that someone else has noticed this potential
> concept
> >as well.
>
> Yes, bravo Nexx :)

Why do I only get accolades for things I pencil-whip? <g>

Nexx, who has decided to stop thinking about Shadowrun, because it makes
everyone else ignore him
Message no. 9
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 09:25:14 -0500
----------
> From: Chris Maxfield <cmaxfiel@****.ORG.AU>
>
> Excellent! One the best explanations of how it feels to be near immortal
> that I've seen in a long time. It's also why I despise those books with
> immortal characters that look, act and feel like any average mortal
human.
>

You missed the point... the elves do feel like any average mortal human...
that's why they withdraw, so they don't get hurt.

Nexx
Message no. 10
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 09:36:29 -0500
----------
> From: Gurth <gurth@******.NL>
> > True, but look at it this way. Imagine that you matured later
than
> > everyone else. I'm talking like, maybe close to five years later.
You
> > don't get your growth spurt until your senior year in high school, you
> > voice is still a child's.
>
> Are you talking about elves now? In that case, sorry, but they mature
just
> as quickly as humans, until they're about 20, and then growth (and
aging)
> seems to stop. I don't remember where this is from, but AFAIK I read it
in
> a FASA-published SR book (or maybe a novel, but I don't think so).

Well, given the fact that an elf's gestation period is 100 days longer
than that of a human (BBB2, pg 36), it would seem logical to me that their
other developmental times were proportionately delayed.

> > Let's say you marry your High school sweetheart
> > (a human girl named... Fayette Myers, now Voigt)
>
> Nice reference :)

Been reading that all day. <g>

>
> [snip rest]
>
> That stil doesn't convince me -- all you're saying is that they live a
lot
> longer and would go through about the same thing you see in the first
> Highlander movie.

It doesn't convince me because you snipped part. Direct quote from my
mail:

"I'm not saying that elves are suddenly going to start acting like they
live forever next week. I'm saying that when that once you've buried
children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren, you're going to start
withdrawing a bit from humans, to keep yourself safe. The first elves
(discounting spike babies), came along in what, 2020-something, right?
They likely grew up amongst humans, married humans, and are starting to
see their spouses and friends from when they were young deteriorate before
their still young eyes."

_Thats_ what my point was, Gurth.

> games. (Even FASA with their "Elven Wines" skill -- why would elves have
> special kinds of wines? Now if that skill were called "Tir Tairngire
> Wines" I could buy it...)

Perhaps Ehran, in addition to being a wordsmith, was also a distiller? <g>

> > > Unconsciousness is no excuse.
> >
> > How about semi-consciousness with a twist of delusional paranoia?
>
> That is :)

Good... I got only a couple hours of sleep last night, and right now the
colors are pretty fucking cool.

***************
Rev. Mark Hall, Bard to the Lady Mari
aka Pope Nexx Many-Scars
*
Is this the real life?
Is this just fantasy?
Caught in a landslide,
No escape from reality.
Open your eyes, Look up to the skies and see,
I'm just a poor boy, I need no sympathy,
Because I'm easy come, easy go, Little high, little low,
Any way the wind blows doesn't really matter to me, to me
-Queen "Bohemian Rhapsody"
*
Heston: 'We Must Arm Ourselves If We Are To Defeat The Apes'
Message no. 11
From: Chris Maxfield <cmaxfiel@****.ORG.AU>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 01:34:22 +1000
At 09:25 20/09/98 -0500, Nexx wrote:
>----------
>> From: Chris Maxfield <cmaxfiel@****.ORG.AU>
>>
>> Excellent! One the best explanations of how it feels to be near immortal
>> that I've seen in a long time. It's also why I despise those books with
>> immortal characters that look, act and feel like any average mortal
>human.
>>
>
>You missed the point... the elves do feel like any average mortal human...
>that's why they withdraw, so they don't get hurt.

No, I got that point, which is why I agreed with your statements. When I
said "feel", I meant from the readers point of view, not the elves.
However, over time, would they still have feelings like an average human?
When they have seen lovers, family and friends reduced to dust again and
again. When homes, cities and even civilizations are as ephemeral as a
mayfly (I'm talking Harlequin, et al, here), when nothing ever lasts, would
they continue to have feelings like an average human?




Chris Maxfield
<cmaxfiel@****.org.au>
------------------------------------------
Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity,
and I'm not sure about the former.
- Albert Einstein
----------------------------------------
Canberra, Australia
Message no. 12
From: Patrick Goodman <remo@***.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 10:55:10 -0500
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Date: Sunday, September 20, 1998 9:20 AM

>> Nexx, that was really good. Nice view on the game cosmology as
>> well. I like it. I also like the fact that someone else has
>> noticed this potential concept as well.
>
>Thank you. Did anyone get where I stole the names from?

Er, uh, well...no. No I didn't. Wish I had...I thought you had just
decided to incorporate, for whatever reason, a piece of your personal life.

The chain of events strikes me as something similar to TIME ENOUGH FOR LOVE,
but it's been a long, long time since I read that, and Lazarus Long
irritated me sufficiently to make me not want to go back in there any time
soon.

--
(>) Texas 2-Step
El Paso: Never surrender. Never forget. Never forgive.
Message no. 13
From: Paul Gettle <RunnerPaul@*****.COM>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 13:40:27 -0400
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

At 01:34 AM 9/21/98 +1000, Chris wrote:
>No, I got that point, which is why I agreed with your statements.
When I
>said "feel", I meant from the readers point of view, not the elves.
>However, over time, would they still have feelings like an average
human?
>When they have seen lovers, family and friends reduced to dust again
and
>again. When homes, cities and even civilizations are as ephemeral as
a
>mayfly (I'm talking Harlequin, et al, here), when nothing ever lasts,
would
>they continue to have feelings like an average human?


"To live on as we have is to leave behind joy, and love, and
companionship, because we know it to be transitory, of the moment. We
know it will turn to ash. Only those, whose lives are brief can
imagine that love .. is eternal. .. You should embrace that remarkable
illusion. It may be the greatest gift your race has ever received."

-- Lorien to Ivanova in Babylon 5:"Into the Fire"

(With thanks to Pasi 'Albert' Ojala for maintaining a B5 quote archive
at:
http://www.cs.tut.fi/~albert/Quotes/B5-quotes.html
because I certainly couldn't have remembered this one on my own.)

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGP for Personal Privacy 5.5.3

iQCVAwUBNgU94KPbvUVI86rNAQHVNgP/XBok7XYeocwboAgRyg4KoRRLXWPxXSOC
loUMgsArEfBzO4VJuQlslJofq8Odw+D0ZNw4fBfN2U56KLwtc6yXV35WhndgbcWp
oruD0HTg6LqUmSOPgLmPgjKvT9XzDfEM0ySFZwRt5nYPNhLExah5zSPjd4AYCsZ2
ZNRAaWy0dqY=
=zMC7
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
--
-- Paul Gettle, #970 of 1000 (RunnerPaul@*****.com)
PGP Fingerprint, Key ID:0x48F3AACD (RSA 1024, created 98/06/26)
C260 94B3 6722 6A25 63F8 0690 9EA2 3344
Message no. 14
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 14:44:54 -0500
----------
> From: Chris Maxfield <cmaxfiel@****.ORG.AU>
> >
> >You missed the point... the elves do feel like any average mortal
human...
> >that's why they withdraw, so they don't get hurt.
>
> No, I got that point, which is why I agreed with your statements. When I
> said "feel", I meant from the readers point of view, not the elves.
> However, over time, would they still have feelings like an average
human?
> When they have seen lovers, family and friends reduced to dust again and
> again. When homes, cities and even civilizations are as ephemeral as a
> mayfly (I'm talking Harlequin, et al, here), when nothing ever lasts,
would
> they continue to have feelings like an average human?

If they were alone in the world? Of course not. Over time they would
have to kill their feelings or live completely outside society. But
they're not alone. There are two full nations of elves, and there are
elven communities scattered across most major cities. They can have a
normal life amongst elves... sure, they'll lose any non-elven friends, but
they'll actually have a support group of elves who have gone through the
exact same thing, and can sympathize, can say "I know how you feel"
without sounding like a goddamned hypocrite.

Nexx
Message no. 15
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Sun, 20 Sep 1998 14:47:49 -0500
----------
> From: Patrick Goodman <remo@***.NET>
> >
> >Thank you. Did anyone get where I stole the names from?
>
> Er, uh, well...no. No I didn't. Wish I had...I thought you had just
> decided to incorporate, for whatever reason, a piece of your personal
life.

Ahhh, but you see, that would necessitate me *having* a personal life...

Nexx
Message no. 16
From: Martin Steffens <chimerae@***.IE>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 12:23:48 +0000
and thus did Chris Maxfield speak on 21 Sep 98 at 1:34:

> However, over time, would they still have feelings like an average human?
> When they have seen lovers, family and friends reduced to dust again and
> again. When homes, cities and even civilizations are as ephemeral as a
> mayfly (I'm talking Harlequin, et al, here), when nothing ever lasts, would
> they continue to have feelings like an average human?

Ah, the lives of the Immortal Elves, my favourite pet-peeve.
They cannot be like us or else they would be completely insane by
now, or had committed suicide a lot time ago. These buggers are
roughly around 40,000 + years old, if I remember the timespan of an
age correctly. No one can even guess what it is to be that old, but
this is what I think:

First of all, the boredom must be immense. "Been there, done that,
seen the film." really is true for these people. They've probably
tried everything they want to try, so live would be a dull,
monotonous, repetitive affair. Reactions like they display in the SR
books are not realistic. There would be no sense in continuing their
power games, simply because it gets boring after a while. How long
can you rule a kingdom without feeling the dark despair that after a
few centuries every day is the same, every plot to overthrow you has
been tried before, and no matter what you do, not one civilization
survives forever, so why bother? The Roman empire lasted for roughly
2,000 years in on form or another. That's 5% of 40,000 and compares
to roughly 4 years of a human's life.

And then after around 20,000 years the magic disappears and
civilization as you knew it collapses. Humans slowly crawl back out
of the dirt, taking around 13,000 years to get somewhere close to
being civilized. What the hell do you do in the meantime? I suspect
that a lot of them wished for a dormant period just like the dragons
have. You would expect them to help humanity to a civilization level
were they at least could have some of their comforts again, but
apparently they withdrew into their own little world.

Now imagine being around 2 maybe up to 5 hundred of your own kind for
thousands and thousands of years. And they love to rekindle old
peeves (just check how many times Alachia still gets slagged for
being a blood elf, and that's after 35,000 years!). Any normal human
would be stark raving mad before 500 years are over and either kill
himself or as many of the others.

Many do get out of there to escape, but enter a human world. Humans
who last just a bare second before dying. They would get about as
attached to a human as we would get to pets who stay alive for less
than a month. That would make the IE's the types of people who don't
mind sacrificing a few hundred people for the Cause, since in the
long run they don't matter anyway. They also would plan much farther
ahead than most people can try to.
I can see them deliberately plotting the downfall of the Roman Empire
to make sure renaissance Europe could evolve from that, but maybe
only a few actually still can manage any enthusiasm to do so.
Alachia as Elizabeth I is ridiculous, she would never bother with
such a short reign, nor would she go for a public position like that.
We you can expect them is behind the throne as true master
manipulators prefer, until they can re-instate the realms of the
past.

Finally the industrial age comes along, and many of them will ignore
it. Simply because they're used to waiting a few hundred years to see
what happens, plus it's close to when the magic will come back, so
why bother. Also most of them will be busy plotting their return to
power once the elves return in force. Destabilizing countries,
sponsor fantasy writers to praise the elves, etc. etc. A few will get
fascinated and suddenly discover that they've found something that
can keep their attention for some time to come. Maybe it's even too
much for them to keep track of, just like we humans are all
specialists now, while a hundred years ago one could become an expect
in many fields.

Then magic returns, and you can almost see them scramble to start
executing their little plans. Within the blink of an eye all those
elven kingdoms are back, and they can show themselves again, and
maybe in a few years don't care if the world knows they're immortal.
Gather the elves of the world in those nations and try to recreate
the culture and feel of those long lost nations of yore.
And that's going to create leagues of problems later when those new
elves who grew up in the modern world, reach maturity and wonder why
they have to live in a fantasy world? And why is it that those same
old farts rule this country while the rest of the world has a
democracy? Obvious some of the more up-to-date IE's can foresee this
happening, but the ones that zoned out when democracies came along
and just wrote them of as a temporary fad, are going to be in for a
suprise.

And personally I think that those IE nations should be very weak on
technology. I grant them immense superiority in the field of magic,
but they mostly should have ignored tech as being inferior to magic.
But no, they had to be "know-all" super heroes... :/

Karina & Martin Steffens
chimerae@***.ie
Message no. 17
From: Steve Eley <sfeley@***.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 10:36:20 -0400
Martin Steffens wrote:
>
> Ah, the lives of the Immortal Elves, my favourite pet-peeve.
> They cannot be like us or else they would be completely insane by
> now, or had committed suicide a lot time ago. These buggers are
> roughly around 40,000 + years old, if I remember the timespan of an
> age correctly.

That number is way off. If you assume these guys were young in the age of
Earthdawn, they'd be between 8,000 and 10,000 years old. There's *no*
indication that any of them were around in the Third World, and strong
indications to the contrary from Harlequin's reminiscences.


> First of all, the boredom must be immense. "Been there, done that,
> seen the film." really is true for these people. They've probably
> tried everything they want to try, so live would be a dull,
> monotonous, repetitive affair.

I disagree. I like Ann Rice's characters' viewpoints on this from
_Interview With the Vampire_ and _The Vampire Lestat_.. You may not
change, but the world around you *does* change. The only way to survive
is to live fully in each age, and strive to change with the world. You
see this in Aina's flashbacks from _Worlds Without End_, too.


> [ . . . ] Reactions like they display in the SR
> books are not realistic. There would be no sense in continuing their
> power games, simply because it gets boring after a while. How long
> can you rule a kingdom without feeling the dark despair that after a
> few centuries every day is the same, every plot to overthrow you has
> been tried before, and no matter what you do, not one civilization
> survives forever, so why bother?

I dunno. How long can a gamer play Shadowrun without feeling the dark
despair that after a few years every shadowrun is the same, every trick
the Johnsons used to screw you over has been tried before, and no matter
what you do, the megacorps still go on crushing the masses, so why
bother? >8->

The point: it's NOT the same. History doesn't literally repeat itself; it
just has a penchant for certain themes. The way the theme *plays* is
different each time.


> [ . . . ] The Roman empire lasted for roughly
> 2,000 years in on form or another. That's 5% of 40,000 and compares
> to roughly 4 years of a human's life.

Again, your 40,000 figure is off.. And hey, four years of my life is a
long time!


> Now imagine being around 2 maybe up to 5 hundred of your own kind for
> thousands and thousands of years.

Two to five HUNDRED? That's *much* more than the source material
indicates.. I got the impression that the number of IE's was more like a
couple dozen.


> Many do get out of there to escape, but enter a human world. Humans
> who last just a bare second before dying. They would get about as
> attached to a human as we would get to pets who stay alive for less
> than a month.

Again I disagree. You're suggesting that immortals would have a different
sense of time.. I think that's only true in a philosophical sense. Their
literal time sense is the same as yours or mine. A day still lasts
approximately twenty-four hours no matter who you are, and sixty years is
still sixty years no matter how many of them you have.


> [ . . . ] That would make the IE's the types of people who don't
> mind sacrificing a few hundred people for the Cause, since in the
> long run they don't matter anyway. They also would plan much farther
> ahead than most people can try to.

This I can see.


> I can see them deliberately plotting the downfall of the Roman Empire
> to make sure renaissance Europe could evolve from that, but maybe
> only a few actually still can manage any enthusiasm to do so.
> Alachia as Elizabeth I is ridiculous, she would never bother with
> such a short reign, nor would she go for a public position like that.

Unless she was looking for a brief, cheap thrill? >8->


> [ snip the rest, which I more or less agree with ]

Interesting reasoning. I do agree with you that anyone who's lived
through thousands of years would be different.. It's just the extent of
the difference (and relative sanity) on which we differ.


Have Fun,
- Steve Eley
sfeley@***.net
Message no. 18
From: Chris Maxfield <cmaxfiel@****.ORG.AU>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Tue, 22 Sep 1998 00:58:00 +1000
At 10:36 21/09/98 -0400, Steve Eley wrote:
>Martin Steffens wrote:
>> Many do get out of there to escape, but enter a human world. Humans
>> who last just a bare second before dying. They would get about as
>> attached to a human as we would get to pets who stay alive for less
>> than a month.
>
>Again I disagree. You're suggesting that immortals would have a different
>sense of time.. I think that's only true in a philosophical sense. Their
>literal time sense is the same as yours or mine. A day still lasts
>approximately twenty-four hours no matter who you are, and sixty years is
>still sixty years no matter how many of them you have.

Mmmm. I remember being a boy and a day would seem to last forever. Yet now
a day passes so very quickly. I really do think that our time-sense changes
as we get older, as we have more and more memories as a yard stick. I read
somewhere that we (usually) only remember things new, different or
important. So, over time, as we experience less and less of things that are
new and different, we remember less of each day. So the days appear to go
faster for people as adults than when they were kids. Imagine how little of
each day you might remember after living thousands of years and, therefore,
how fleeting the days might appear.


Chris Maxfield We are restless because of incessant
<cmaxfiel@****.org.au> change, but we would be frightened if
Canberra, Australia change were stopped.
Message no. 19
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 10:28:51 -0500
----------
> From: Martin Steffens <chimerae@***.IE>
>
> and thus did Chris Maxfield speak on 21 Sep 98 at 1:34:
>
> > However, over time, would they still have feelings like an average
human?
> > When they have seen lovers, family and friends reduced to dust again
and
> > again. When homes, cities and even civilizations are as ephemeral as a
> > mayfly (I'm talking Harlequin, et al, here), when nothing ever lasts,
would
> > they continue to have feelings like an average human?
>
> Ah, the lives of the Immortal Elves, my favourite pet-peeve.
> They cannot be like us or else they would be completely insane by
> now, or had committed suicide a lot time ago. These buggers are
> roughly around 40,000 + years old, if I remember the timespan of an
> age correctly. No one can even guess what it is to be that old, but
> this is what I think:

It's a near-perfect deconstruction, Martin, but they're not 40,000. An
age is 2500 years, with the peak (or valley) coming at 1250.

***************
Rev. Mark Hall, Bard to the Lady Mari
aka Pope Nexx Many-Scars
*
I am a rovin' sportin' blade
they call me Jack of all Trades
I always found my chief delight
in courting pretty fair maids.
-"The Dublin Jack of All Trades"
Message no. 20
From: Tim Kerby <drekhead@***.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 11:38:11 -0400
On 22 Sep 98, at 0:58, Chris Maxfield wrote:

> At 10:36 21/09/98 -0400, Steve Eley wrote:
> >
> >Again I disagree. You're suggesting that immortals would have a
> >different sense of time.. I think that's only true in a philosophical
> >sense. Their literal time sense is the same as yours or mine. A day
> >still lasts approximately twenty-four hours no matter who you are, and
> >sixty years is still sixty years no matter how many of them you have.
>
> Mmmm. I remember being a boy and a day would seem to last forever. Yet now
> a day passes so very quickly. I really do think that our time-sense
> changes as we get older, as we have more and more memories as a yard
> stick.

This is true. Think about it. When your a six-year old kid, a year is
1/6th of your life. When your 30, a year is 1/30th of your life. Time
is the same, but your perception of time changes as you get older.
It's a fact. I read something about a study they did on it.

Now imagine Harelequin and Ehran.... a year is 1/10,000th of their
life. That's like a day to a 30-year old human.

"It's your birthday, again? Has it been a year already? Seems like
just yesterday..."

--

=================================================================
- Tim Kerby - drekhead@***.net - ICQ-UIN 2883757 -
-----------------------------------------------------------------
"Reality is the only obstacle to happiness." - Unknown
Message no. 21
From: Nexx <nexx@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 10:45:01 -0500
----------
> From: Steve Eley <sfeley@***.NET>
> > Now imagine being around 2 maybe up to 5 hundred of your own kind for
> > thousands and thousands of years.
>
> Two to five HUNDRED? That's *much* more than the source material
> indicates.. I got the impression that the number of IE's was more like
a
> couple dozen.

I think he means two (as in, less than three) through (as in including 3,
4, 5, 6, 23, 69) 500, not 200-500.

***************
Rev. Mark Hall, Bard to the Lady Mari
aka Pope Nexx Many-Scars
*
I am a rovin' sportin' blade
they call me Jack of all Trades
I always found my chief delight
in courting pretty fair maids.
-"The Dublin Jack of All Trades"
Message no. 22
From: Gurth <gurth@******.NL>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 19:57:45 +0200
According to Tim Kerby, at 11:38 on 21 Sep 98, the word on the street was...

> This is true. Think about it. When your a six-year old kid, a year is
> 1/6th of your life. When your 30, a year is 1/30th of your life. Time
> is the same, but your perception of time changes as you get older.
> It's a fact. I read something about a study they did on it.

But Tim, you're _old_, remember? ;)

> "It's your birthday, again? Has it been a year already? Seems like
> just yesterday..."

I'm not sure they'd still celebrate their birthdays. Or even remember the
date -- after all, the calendar has changed a couple of times, and I have
this feeling that after a few millennia (or 24 years) you just don't
bother anymore.

--
Gurth@******.nl - http://www.xs4all.nl/~gurth/index.html
Unconsciousness is no excuse.
-> NERPS Project Leader * ShadowRN GridSec * Unofficial Shadowrun Guru <-
-> The Plastic Warriors Page: http://www.xs4all.nl/~gurth/plastic.html <-
-> The New Character Mortuary: http://www.electricferret.com/mortuary/ <-

GC3.1: GAT/! d-(dpu) s:- !a>? C+(++)@ U P L E? W(++) N o? K- w+ O V? PS+
PE Y PGP- t(+) 5++ X++ R+++>$ tv+(++) b++@ DI? D+ G(++) e h! !r(---) y?
Incubated into the First Church of the Sqooshy Ball, 21-05-1998
Message no. 23
From: Fixer <fixer@*******.TLH.FL.US>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 14:33:58 -0400
On Mon, 21 Sep 1998, Gurth wrote:

->According to Tim Kerby, at 11:38 on 21 Sep 98, the word on the street was...
->
<snip>
->> "It's your birthday, again? Has it been a year already? Seems like
->> just yesterday..."
->
->I'm not sure they'd still celebrate their birthdays. Or even remember the
->date -- after all, the calendar has changed a couple of times, and I have
->this feeling that after a few millennia (or 24 years) you just don't
->bother anymore.

I'm not old at 25, but I stopped celebrating my birthday about
four years ago, after a hellacious night on my 21st. I doubt seriously
these folks celebrate birthdays. They probably celebrate "Happy Century!"
or "Happy Millenia" or something.

Fixer --------------} The easy I do before breakfast,
the difficult I do all day long,
the impossible only during the week,
and miracles performed on an as-needed basis....

Now tell me, what was your problem?
Message no. 24
From: Max Rible <slothman@*********.ORG>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 11:44:11 -0700
Anyone in the Twilight Brigade campaign, hit "delete" now..

At 12:23 9/21/98 +0000, Martin Steffens wrote:
>and thus did Chris Maxfield speak on 21 Sep 98 at 1:34:
>> However, over time, would they still have feelings like an average human?
>> When they have seen lovers, family and friends reduced to dust again and
>> again. When homes, cities and even civilizations are as ephemeral as a
>> mayfly (I'm talking Harlequin, et al, here), when nothing ever lasts, would
>> they continue to have feelings like an average human?

>Ah, the lives of the Immortal Elves, my favourite pet-peeve.
>They cannot be like us or else they would be completely insane by
>now, or had committed suicide a lot time ago. These buggers are
>roughly around 40,000 + years old, if I remember the timespan of an
>age correctly.

One Age is about 5125 years, according to the Mayan calendar.
According to Ehran the Scribe:

"Atlantis sank on August 12, 3113 BC, thus marking the end of the Fourth
World and the beginning of the Fifth. The Sixth World has begun, and will
end, according to the Mayan calendar, on April 4, 7137 AD."

This means most IE's are probably about eight to ten thousand years
old.

The way I run things, all IE's *are* insane. The IE's have the
*magic* to live forever, which they may have acquired from the
Great Dragons, but they don't have the *philosophy*, the coping
mechanisms, to deal well with immortality.

Naturally, all the completely dysfunctional IE's have died by now.
There are only two or three dozen left, as per _Threats_.

Most of them keep their grip on reality by indulging in Machiavellian
games with their peers, in imitation of the Great Dragons. Harlequin
is one of the exceptions: he's crazy like a fox, alternating bouts of
alcoholism and running around desperately throwing himself into one
cause after another, both in an attempt to forget loss of his beloved
Sereatha, the City of Spires, where he was part of a group of Knights
dedicated to preserving all that was good in elven tradition-- and is
now completely lost. (Performing the ritual of chal'han makes him an
extreme loose cannon: IE's may scheme and intrigue, but the possibility
that one might *kill* another is insane-- losing one more playmate erodes
that much more of their collective grip on sanity.)

Aithne Oakforest, for contrast, is a former Blood Elf who lost it
when the magic went away and so did his thorns-- the pain of being
a Blood Elf did most of the work, and then *losing* the thorns and
recognizing the futility of all that suffering finished the job.
He's been a drunk and a mercenary for the past five thousand years;
he dried out mostly during the Renaissance, but he's still bent
out of his mind, as we can see from his little episode with the
rose bushes.

>First of all, the boredom must be immense. "Been there, done that,
>seen the film." really is true for these people. They've probably
>tried everything they want to try, so live would be a dull,
>monotonous, repetitive affair. Reactions like they display in the SR
>books are not realistic.

The way they act in the SR books is due to massive denial. The ones
who aren't in denial killed themselves (or slipped up and got themselves
killed) early in the rise of the Roman Empire, if not earlier.
(I figure watching Alexander the Great and then Rome just a little while
later would just *get* to them...)

> What the hell do you do in the meantime? I suspect
>that a lot of them wished for a dormant period just like the dragons
>have. You would expect them to help humanity to a civilization level
>were they at least could have some of their comforts again, but
>apparently they withdrew into their own little world.

You introduce the Neolithic Revolution to them so they can start
brewing liquor again so you can spend centuries to millennia drinking
to help forget the glories of your past civilization. Unfortunately,
they're Immune to Poisons and Pathogens, so they can't actually kill
their brain cells, so they have to keep drinking to forget...

>Alachia as Elizabeth I is ridiculous, she would never bother with
>such a short reign, nor would she go for a public position like that.

I've edited that out of continuity... along with a lot of other stuff,
mostly from Sargent and Gascoigne...

--
%% Max Rible %%% max@********.com %%% http://www.amurgsval.org/~slothman/ %%
%% "Ham is good... Glowing *tattooed* ham is *bad*!" - the Tick %%
Message no. 25
From: Martin Steffens <chimerae@***.IE>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 22:41:43 +0000
First I like to say that these were just a few ideas I had about
being immortal, and I like everyones input who thinks otherwise or
agrees, since none of use can really know what it is like, but maybe
we can come to a sort of mutual idea (or more likely a few completely
different ideas :).

and thus did Steve Eley speak on 21 Sep 98 at 10:36:

> > roughly around 40,000 + years old, if I remember the timespan of an
> > age correctly.
>
> That number is way off. If you assume these guys were young in the age of
> Earthdawn, they'd be between 8,000 and 10,000 years old. There's *no*
> indication that any of them were around in the Third World, and strong
> indications to the contrary from Harlequin's reminiscences.

Darn, I'm in the middle of a move right now, so I do not have any
reference materials around. I figured that an age, as in the fifth
world was around 20,000 years, but what's the real time?

Plus there must be elves around from before that. The second age was
magical too and there were records of that time about the horrors.
Maybe the IE population is set at a certain number, but as an age
advanced IE's die of other causes, so at the beginning of a new
magical age the population gets refreshed.

> I disagree. I like Ann Rice's characters' viewpoints on this from
> _Interview With the Vampire_ and _The Vampire Lestat_.. You may not
> change, but the world around you *does* change. The only way to survive
> is to live fully in each age, and strive to change with the world. You
> see this in Aina's flashbacks from _Worlds Without End_, too.

Compared to the elves those Rice Vampires are kiddies. Eventually you
must get depressed from saving the world over and over again, and
just let someone else do it for a change. Also the ED world doesn't
show much change apart from the horrors. It always appeared to me as
a frozen in time typical fantasy world. Nations might change but
essentially the world and people stay the same. So they would have
lived in that unchanging world for most of their lives. And then they
plunge into the darkness of the fifth world where nothing much
happens for the first few thousand years or so (change number
accordingly to the exact start which I don't remember).

> I dunno. How long can a gamer play Shadowrun without feeling the dark
> despair that after a few years every shadowrun is the same, every trick
> the Johnsons used to screw you over has been tried before, and no matter
> what you do, the megacorps still go on crushing the masses, so why
> bother? >8->

Try playing it for hundred years. People move from game to game
simply because it's not interesting anymore. And the problem is that
the more intelligent you are, the easier you get bored.

> The point: it's NOT the same. History doesn't literally repeat itself; it
> just has a penchant for certain themes. The way the theme *plays* is
> different each time.

I didn't say that it did, but the way things go must be
intimately familiar to them after a thousand years or so.
"Oh, god, here we go again, he's plotting to overthrow me... sigh...
shall I let him succeed just for fun?"

> Again, your 40,000 figure is off.. And hey, four years of my life is a
> long time!

Yes, if it was off the first time it would be still off here, I
tend to be consistently right or wrong :). Four years might be long,
but now try to imagine how it is to live in a differently ruled
country every four years or make it eight. "Hey, we have the USA.
Oups, now it's the UCAS. New Socialist Nation of the Americas; Royal
Kingdom of America, etc. etc. And that's in comparison to one of the
more lasting empires in our history (yes, I know there are longer
lasting ones).

> Two to five HUNDRED? That's *much* more than the source material
> indicates.. I got the impression that the number of IE's was more like a
> couple dozen.

I don't know, I was just making a wild guess using the famous "tip of
the iceberg" formula :).

> Again I disagree. You're suggesting that immortals would have a different
> sense of time.. I think that's only true in a philosophical sense. Their
> literal time sense is the same as yours or mine. A day still lasts
> approximately twenty-four hours no matter who you are, and sixty years is
> still sixty years no matter how many of them you have.

Untrue. Consider how time seems to condense when you do get older.
Weeks tended to last years for me when I was younger, now they fly
by. Literally they live the same seconds as we do, but perceive them
differently. Sense of time is proven to be slower for older
people. What's a decade for someone who lives forever, and what does
missing a decade of your life mean to you?

> > Alachia as Elizabeth I is ridiculous, she would never bother with
> > such a short reign, nor would she go for a public position like that.

> Unless she was looking for a brief, cheap thrill? >8->

:). Yeah, maybe just for the heck of it, see if she can still do
it... Could be a test for the real thing.

> Interesting reasoning. I do agree with you that anyone who's lived
> through thousands of years would be different.. It's just the extent of
> the difference (and relative sanity) on which we differ.

Lets try it out and speak again in a millennium :).

Martin Steffens
chimerae@***.ie
Message no. 26
From: Martin Steffens <chimerae@***.IE>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 23:28:55 +0000
and thus did Max Rible speak on 21 Sep 98 at 11:44:

> The way I run things, all IE's *are* insane. The IE's have the
> *magic* to live forever, which they may have acquired from the
> Great Dragons, but they don't have the *philosophy*, the coping
> mechanisms, to deal well with immortality.
[snip rest]

Woah, I love this. It's even worse than I pictured them and I thought
I was pushing it a bit. This one goes to the collectors items.



Karina & Martin Steffens
chimerae@***.ie
Message no. 27
From: Anjo Verde <Chant_Obscur@*******.FR>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Tue, 22 Sep 1998 00:14:18 +0200
-----Message d'origine-----
De : Max Rible <slothman@*********.ORG>
Date : lundi 21 septembre 1998 20:48
Objet : Re: Elves and Humans


>The way I run things, all IE's *are* insane. The IE's have the
>*magic* to live forever, which they may have acquired from the
>Great Dragons, but they don't have the *philosophy*, the coping
>mechanisms, to deal well with immortality.
>
>Naturally, all the completely dysfunctional IE's have died by now.
>There are only two or three dozen left, as per _Threats_.
>
>Most of them keep their grip on reality by indulging in Machiavellian
>games with their peers, in imitation of the Great Dragons. Harlequin
>is one of the exceptions: he's crazy like a fox, alternating bouts of
>alcoholism and running around desperately throwing himself into one
>cause after another, both in an attempt to forget loss of his beloved
>Sereatha, the City of Spires, where he was part of a group of Knights
>dedicated to preserving all that was good in elven tradition-- and is
>now completely lost. (Performing the ritual of chal'han makes him an
>extreme loose cannon: IE's may scheme and intrigue, but the possibility
>that one might *kill* another is insane-- losing one more playmate erodes
>that much more of their collective grip on sanity.)


I see things in a view close to yours, though IMO they're not insane,
but bordering on insanity. They keep their grasp on reality by
indulging in their favorite pasttimes like mindgames for Harlequin,
art and drinking for Aina, sociology for Ehran and world domination
for Alachia. These occupations help them maintain their grasp on
the present moment, and thus not to get overwhelmed by their own
memories. BTW, Harlequin never intended to kill Ehran. Not only
do I think their relation is too strong for him to do such a thing
(AFAIK, they might even have been lovers!) but it is strictly forbidden
for an elder to physically attack another. The rule must be strongly
enforced or Alachia would have been dead for quite some time.

>Aithne Oakforest, for contrast, is a former Blood Elf who lost it
>when the magic went away and so did his thorns-- the pain of being
>a Blood Elf did most of the work, and then *losing* the thorns and
>recognizing the futility of all that suffering finished the job.
>He's been a drunk and a mercenary for the past five thousand years;
>he dried out mostly during the Renaissance, but he's still bent
>out of his mind, as we can see from his little episode with the
>rose bushes.


No, the rose bushes episode comes from the fact that if he survived
the rite of thorns, his wife and children died. As for his temper, it comes
from repeatedly losing those he loves (I won't tell, it would spoil
Caroline Spector's ED novels).


>>Alachia as Elizabeth I is ridiculous, she would never bother with
>>such a short reign, nor would she go for a public position like that.


>I've edited that out of continuity... along with a lot of other stuff,
>mostly from Sargent and Gascoigne...


Whatever! It's not like this will have any influence on the game.
Anyway I feel like pointing out that she _is_ power-mad and would
see such an action as her first step towards world domination.
Hence such a bid for power and her association with nazis and
the third Reich.

Anjo Verde
Message no. 28
From: Max Rible <slothman@*********.ORG>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 15:51:49 -0700
At 23:28 9/21/98 +0000, Martin Steffens wrote:
>and thus did Max Rible speak on 21 Sep 98 at 11:44:
>
>> The way I run things, all IE's *are* insane. The IE's have the
>> *magic* to live forever, which they may have acquired from the
>> Great Dragons, but they don't have the *philosophy*, the coping
>> mechanisms, to deal well with immortality.
>[snip rest]
>
>Woah, I love this. It's even worse than I pictured them and I thought
>I was pushing it a bit. This one goes to the collectors items.

Thank you. Elves in SR are ubermenschen, so I feel a need to throw in
a dark side. It's only 2055 right now in my campaign, so there aren't
hundreds of Elven "It's not even my fragging mid-life yet!" Crisis
Counseling Centers springing up... I have more notes on the IE's
at my web site at http://www.amurgsval.org/shadowrun/players.html --
anyone in the Twilight Brigade, do *not* poke your nose in there! :-)
I think you'll like what I've done with Lofwyr.

I also find the Net's huge outcry against IE's and the ED/SR connection
to be a challenge: to use them *well*, rather than making everything out
to be the work of immortal elves.

--
%% Max Rible %%% max@********.com %%% http://www.amurgsval.org/~slothman/ %%
%% "Ham is good... Glowing *tattooed* ham is *bad*!" - the Tick %%
Message no. 29
From: Anjo Verde <Chant_Obscur@*******.FR>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Tue, 22 Sep 1998 01:18:56 +0200
-----Message d'origine-----
De : Max Rible <slothman@*********.ORG>
Date : mardi 22 septembre 1998 00:55
Objet : Re: Elves and Humans

>I also find the Net's huge outcry against IE's and the ED/SR connection
>to be a challenge: to use them *well*, rather than making everything out
>to be the work of immortal elves.
>

I tend to agree with you. I feel that FASA's only real mistake with IE is in
the manichean approach. For all their wishful thinking, dragons and
elders can't possibly be responsible for every important event.

Anjo Verde
Message no. 30
From: Max Rible <slothman@*********.ORG>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 16:08:29 -0700
At 00:14 9/22/98 +0200, Anjo Verde wrote:
>I see things in a view close to yours, though IMO they're not insane,
>but bordering on insanity.

Mere wealth and power can drive ordinary human beings insane. (It's
insidious: if you're rich, people will treat you differently because
you *might* bestow largesse on them. This means that it's harder to
get the kind of social feedback that tells you you're behaving in a
decent manner, allowing you to build up a completely different image
of the way the world works than it actually does. This can create a
functional person who still doesn't have a grip on reality.)
I figure the IE's are well off the deep end... but *very* functional.

> BTW, Harlequin never intended to kill Ehran.

That's obvious from the module...

> Not only
>do I think their relation is too strong for him to do such a thing
>(AFAIK, they might even have been lovers!) but it is strictly forbidden
>for an elder to physically attack another. The rule must be strongly
>enforced or Alachia would have been dead for quite some time.

...but Harlequin is unhinged enough that Ehran couldn't be *sure* that
Harlequin wasn't going to kill him, or there wouldn't have been quite
the tension there. :-) I had the same idea about them being lovers when
the Richard the Lion-Hearted bit turned up in Dunkelzahn's Will...

>No, the rose bushes episode comes from the fact that if he survived
>the rite of thorns, his wife and children died. As for his temper, it comes
>from repeatedly losing those he loves (I won't tell, it would spoil
>Caroline Spector's ED novels).

How did you get access to said novels? Did they get published while
I wasn't looking? (Amazon.com says Scars still hasn't come out.)
I'm just doing a lot of extrapolating based on very little data...

--
%% Max Rible %%% max@********.com %%% http://www.amurgsval.org/~slothman/ %%
%% "Ham is good... Glowing *tattooed* ham is *bad*!" - the Tick %%
Message no. 31
From: K in the Shadows <Ereskanti@***.COM>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 19:28:53 EDT
In a message dated 9/20/1998 5:39:16 AM US Eastern Standard Time,
gurth@******.NL writes:

>
> That stil doesn't convince me -- all you're saying is that they live a lot
> longer and would go through about the same thing you see in the first
> Highlander movie. I don't really see how that should affect the way elves
> behave in SR (because the oldest elf is 49 years old in 2060, discounting
> spike babies of course), and certainly not how it relates to the "elven
> culture" idea so many _players_ seem to insist on caryring over from other
> games. (Even FASA with their "Elven Wines" skill -- why would elves have
> special kinds of wines? Now if that skill were called "Tir Tairngire
> Wines" I could buy it...)

i snipped any/all references to Nexx's really impressive comparison to why
Elves might act differently *further down the line* in SR, versus the here and
now.

Here's a thought to consider Gurth. Do you have a brother, a younger kin that
you see moderately often? If not, I'm sure you now people considerably
younger than yourself as well as people considerably older (smirk ;). Those
people behave differently as it is. Whether it's defined as personality, or
age, or maturitization, it all comes down to a difference in behavior based
upon the sum/collected experiences of an individual.

Now unless the elven mind doesn't retain long-term memories well, say anything
over 20-30 years, the elf is going to retain a lot of information and a lot
more experiences than a human will (as an example). After a hundred years,
the elf is going to probably begin to notice the various cycling of fashion
trends amongst the humans, who often say "this is new", when the elf will
correct them and say "it's new to *you*, your great grandparents used to do
the same thing in their day". Make that two hundred or more years and s/he is
likely to really notice the craziness that the shorter-life term species (like
humans) are likely to do. They rush things a bit in politics and invention,
often making mistakes when if they had more time, and were aware of that
advantage, could simply "lay back" and let things move along and die out.

How many "elven characters" are out that were amongst the first elves born.
Back in the 20's??? Imagine that person's outlook with all the massive
changes and having survived them all? And *that* is something that could be
played in the rules as they exist in any edition.

Imagine the experiences of a 40-50 year old in the body of a 25 year old?
Good God, imagine if someone like (I'm sorry, I'm gonna say it) Clinton were
able to do this, or Ross Perot, or anyone else with ties to multiple political
factions???

I'm sorry, it's about this time -I- would seek out organizations like the
Black Lodge, beg them to sign me up, volunteer to be a sacrificee for some
massive Ritual Hellblast, end their long-term butts, and go from there....

-K (was that a rant??? ;)
Message no. 32
From: Anjo Verde <Chant_Obscur@*******.FR>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Tue, 22 Sep 1998 01:47:06 +0200
-----Message d'origine-----
De : Max Rible <slothman@*********.ORG>
Date : mardi 22 septembre 1998 01:15
Objet : Re: Elves and Humans

>I had the same idea about them being lovers when
>the Richard the Lion-Hearted bit turned up in Dunkelzahn's Will...

Yes, that and the ambiguous line in Post Mortem.

>How did you get access to said novels? Did they get published while
>I wasn't looking? (Amazon.com says Scars still hasn't come out.)
>I'm just doing a lot of extrapolating based on very little data...

There was a thread I started here a few days ago. Though they weren't
published in English, they were translated and published in France.
If you want to know what they're about (considering that they might
never get published in English), e-mail me.

Anjo Verde
Message no. 33
From: Rick J Federle <griffinhq@****.COM>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 23:09:47 -0400
On Mon, 21 Sep 1998 22:41:43 +0000 Martin Steffens <chimerae@***.IE>
writes:
>First I like to say that these were just a few ideas I had about
>being immortal, and I like everyones input who thinks otherwise or
>agrees, since none of use can really know what it is like, but maybe
>we can come to a sort of mutual idea (or more likely a few completely
>different ideas :).
>
>and thus did Steve Eley speak on 21 Sep 98 at 10:36:
>
>> > roughly around 40,000 + years old, if I remember the timespan of
>an
>> > age correctly.
>>
>> That number is way off. If you assume these guys were young in the
>age of
>> Earthdawn, they'd be between 8,000 and 10,000 years old. There's
>*no*
>> indication that any of them were around in the Third World, and
>strong
>> indications to the contrary from Harlequin's reminiscences.
>
This is confirmed in Worlds Without End. Aina's age is placed in the
eight thousands as I recall. Also, the age of Horrors (named, anyway)
lasted less than a millenia.
_____________________________________________________________________
You don't need to buy Internet access to use free Internet e-mail.
Get completely free e-mail from Juno at http://www.juno.com
Or call Juno at (800) 654-JUNO [654-5866]
Message no. 34
From: Michael Coleman <mscoleman@********.NET>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Tue, 22 Sep 1998 00:07:25 -0500
> I doubt seriously
> these folks <<IEs>> celebrate birthdays. They probably celebrate
"Happy
Century!"
> or "Happy Millenia" or something.
>
> Fixer

IEs still might track their birthdays because in many cultures the day of
ones birth has mystical significance. They might not celebrate it. But
they would know the day, year, the sign, and all the other particulars.

Mike
Message no. 35
From: "Ratinac, Rand (NSW)" <RRatinac@*****.REDCROSS.ORG.AU>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Tue, 22 Sep 1998 15:19:48 +1000
> > I doubt seriously
> > these folks <<IEs>> celebrate birthdays. They probably celebrate
> "Happy
> Century!"
> > or "Happy Millenia" or something.
> >
> > Fixer
>
> IEs still might track their birthdays because in many cultures the day
> of
> ones birth has mystical significance. They might not celebrate it.
> But
> they would know the day, year, the sign, and all the other
> particulars.
>
> Mike
>
You've also got to realise that it's unlikely they have the same
calendar we do. After all, our calendar is based on a system that is
much younger than the IEs. Possibly their year was longer or shorter
than ours - and that they still keep track using it. I'm sure a lot will
have gone over to the modern system, merely for the sheer convenience of
it, but a lot of them (especially the more hidebound ones - can anyone
say 'Alachia'?) probably mark birthdays and other important dates using
their own calendars. I bet you the most powerful of them have their own
little 'Immortal Elf Calendar' secreted somewhere in their homes. Anyone
who's involved in predicting the future (or foreseeing it, or know
something is going to happen at this time because that spirit said so)
is going to need to hold onto their own method of telling time in order
to get things right. (Can you imagine knowing that this huge war is
going to break out in a certain place at a certain date - and then being
stuck in the middle of it because it started four days before you
thought it would because this damned human calendar you're using is
off?!?!) And if my previous conjecture about differing lengths of
calendars is true, that could mean the IEs are actually a lot older or
younger than we believe...hmmm...not a big thing in and of itself, but
it could become so...

Doc'
Message no. 36
From: Larry Stanton <DethDrake@***.COM>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Tue, 22 Sep 1998 21:24:34 EDT
And thusly did chimerae@***.IE (Karina & Martin Steffens) scribe:

<< They cannot be like us or else they would be completely insane by
now, or had committed suicide a lot time ago. These buggers are
roughly around 40,000 + years old, if I remember the timespan of an
age correctly. >>

The Mayan calendar is complex. Years of 260-, 360-, and 365-days duration
run concurrently. The Long Count (360-day) calendar records time intervals in
excess of billions (yes, billions) of years. On December 23, 2012, the 13th
Baktun will be completed, a day that occurs once every 8000 Mayan Tuns (about
7890 modern years).
Were these Immortal Elves you speak of born during the time of the 1st
World? Since it has only been approximately 40,000+/- years since the
beginning of that World......What planet did these Elves migrate from.....at
least from the Mayan point of view, since the world had only just come into
existence 40,000 or so years ago by their reckoning.
Just food for thought.

Larry Stanton
DethDrake@***.com
"So let me get this straight, Mr President. If you walk in and find that I
have my manhood in Chelsea's mouth, its alright by you, since that isn't sex
as you understand it?"
Message no. 37
From: Fixer <fixer@*******.TLH.FL.US>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Wed, 23 Sep 1998 09:15:19 -0400
On Tue, 22 Sep 1998, Larry Stanton wrote:

<snip mayan calendar bit>
-> Were these Immortal Elves you speak of born during the time of the 1st
->World? Since it has only been approximately 40,000+/- years since the
->beginning of that World......What planet did these Elves migrate from.....at
->least from the Mayan point of view, since the world had only just come into
->existence 40,000 or so years ago by their reckoning.

I know little or nothing about IEs but I doubt they COULD have
originated from the first world, since it would not have been magically
active (it's magical only on even worlds). Someone said it wouldn't have
happened in the second either, although the Horrors were apparently there,
as well as someone to fight them (Dragons, maybe?). The fourth world
(from what I understand) is where IEs first showed their faces, as it
were.
If I'm way off someone let me know, eh?

->"So let me get this straight, Mr President. If you walk in and find that I
->have my manhood in Chelsea's mouth, its alright by you, since that isn't sex
->as you understand it?"

I find this very funny. ]:-)

Fixer --------------} The easy I do before breakfast,
the difficult I do all day long,
the impossible only during the week,
and miracles performed on an as-needed basis....

Now tell me, what was your problem?
Message no. 38
From: Martin Steffens <chimerae@***.IE>
Subject: Re: Elves and Humans
Date: Wed, 23 Sep 1998 16:35:16 +0000
and thus did Larry Stanton speak on 22 Sep 98 at 21:24:

[snip]
> Were these Immortal Elves you speak of born during the time of the 1st
> World? Since it has only been approximately 40,000+/- years since the
> beginning of that World......What planet did these Elves migrate from.....at
> least from the Mayan point of view, since the world had only just come into
> existence 40,000 or so years ago by their reckoning.
> Just food for thought.

Nah, I just messed up the numbers.
BTW, the first world would be a magic-less one, so I wonder if
there's any information / living being still in existence from that
age. Is there any hinting in SR or more likely ED about this age and
how it was supposed to look?

Or for that matter the second age?

Karina & Martin Steffens
chimerae@***.ie

Further Reading

If you enjoyed reading about Elves and Humans, you may also be interested in:

Disclaimer

These messages were posted a long time ago on a mailing list far, far away. The copyright to their contents probably lies with the original authors of the individual messages, but since they were published in an electronic forum that anyone could subscribe to, and the logs were available to subscribers and most likely non-subscribers as well, it's felt that re-publishing them here is a kind of public service.