From: | Sir Philos Nex <philos@****.NET> |
---|---|
Subject: | Re: Shadowland question and GM only information |
Date: | Tue, 26 Aug 1997 19:30:56 -0400 |
> Why didn't FASA mark books GM-only and PC/GM in the first place? It's
> always petty nice, to discuss whether the players may read the book or not
> (My GM handles it this way: If he get's the book first, it's GM-only.
> Works for me, as he doesn't want to buy English-books..;))).
>
I'm glad there's no stupid GM book. Personally I think that the game works
perfectly. I tell my players that everything in every SR book is open to
them. If they want to read the damn notes on how to run a good game in the BBB
then fine, let them. But I also tell them that the rules are in no way set in
stone and that no item listed is set in stone. If a particular book says that
"this is the safest and most reliable weapon on the market" I might feel that
this particular gun that was just purchased was one from a shipment of flawed
barrels... or perhaps I might decide that it's just marketing and that the
weapon is the shittiest thing you've ever seen (short of an amercan congressmen
:) I think that so long as my players know the distinction between character
knowledge and player knowledge I don't mind. I do try to keep the non-magical
types from reading the grimoir (but eventually they all play magicians or
adepts so it's a very silly attempt on my part :). I just figure that all
players will have access to most (if not all) items in most of the books.
Please understand, access doesn't mean that they can walk next door and pick up
some MilSpec shyte but if they're into that military thang, they'll know what
an assault cannon is, they'll have heard and read of the specs of power armour
in some magazine and for those with the ability to access the matrix with any
skill, ALL the SR books are posted as public domain on Shadowland.. so why, as
a GM would you restrict those books? I think we all have gotten to the point
that if someone says "Hey what's the damage code for XXXX gun?" most of us
could reply from memory... and as a GM I get annoyed by players who do that
too... but you know what.. shit happens :) And it's easier for me to just ask
"does anyone remember what the armour rating for medium security armour is?
I've forgotten." and get two correct replies.
Let's not get FASA into the AD$D mode.. where the only thing that the DM
book had that should have been DM only was the magical item section... and
perhaps the xp section. Why would you keep movement restricted information?
Bah. I like informed people. I hate idiots... I 've had to play with enough
of them.
--
Andrew Dominas
AKA Sir Philos Nex
3rd Year Honours Business Administration U of Windsor
Jedi Knight
-----BEGIN GEEK CODE BLOCK-----
Version: 3.1
GB/O d-@>++ s+:+> a-- C++++>$ U P L>- !E----? W+@>++ N++ o K-?
w---(-)>-
O+++
!M- V? PS+ PE++>+++ Y-- !PGP- t !5 X R++* tv- b+ DI++++(+++++)>+++++ D++ G
e++
h>+ r+++ y+++++(reset)
------END GEEK CODE BLOCK------