From: | Paul Gettle <RunnerPaul@*****.COM> |
---|---|
Subject: | Re: Vegetarian Elves |
Date: | Mon, 28 Sep 1998 23:15:22 -0400 |
At 06:27 PM 9/28/98 -0700, Max wrote:
>>The menu for THE Sports
>>Bar includes "burgers, dogs, wings and nachos." I'll grant you that
>>those are probably soy-burgers, soy-dogs, and soy based Buffalo
Wings,
>>but they are most definately intended to resemble meat.
>A lot of elves will have grown up with people coming up with non-meat
>versions of burgers, dogs, wings, and nachos for them when it turned
>out they couldn't handle the real thing, and could very well have a
>cultural preference for them. I'd say that entry is inconclusive.
I suppose it's a matter of when nutrisoy became the staple food for
the majority of the populace. Back during the first waves of UGE in
2011, the world was only in the first years of the resource rush.
Native Americans hadn't taken over the bulk of North America yet. I
would expect that the price of natural foods, including real meat,
hadn't skyrocketed yet when the first generation of elves were
starting on solid foods.
If we assume that elven vegetarianism has a biological basis, then
it's clear that the parents of the first elves would have faced a
quandry when they found out that their toddlers couldn't digest meat
protein. Are you honestly suggesting that these parents would have
come up with vegtable based foods that were made look and taste like
actual meat prodcuts, instead of adopting some of the more traditonal
vegetarian diets for their pointy-eared children?
If a parent knows that their child will be stuck with a dietary
restriction for the rest of their life, wouldn't it make sense to
steer the child away from the taste of what they can't eat, instead of
getting them used to the taste? Even if parents did raise their young
elven children on meat-like substitutes, there's always the risk that
the child might someday think they can try the real thing, only to
find that they can't digest it. I don't think many parents would want
to take that risk.
And if such an accident does occur, where someone eats something their
system can't handle, often times, all it takes is one lone incident to
turn that person away from that type of food for a long while. People
are very prone to classical conditioning when it comes to matters of
food and digestion.
If elven vegetarianism is biological, I really can not see where they
would have "grown up with" burgers, hot dogs, and chicken (or even
sushi), even with the advent of nutrisoy in the later years.
I think elven vegetarianism is merely a cultural trait, tied in with
the New-Agey, Back to Nature trends in elven culture. This was, just
as was suggested in the BBB2, mistaken for a biological trait by the
scientists who authored the racial descriptions.
Is there any other place in SR cannon, other than these reports with
their disclaimer suggesting bias, that suggests that elves are
vegetarian specifically because of biology? If not, then I'm going to
go with the evidence I've found in Tir Tairngire (one of two SR
sourcebooks specifically about elves).
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGP for Personal Privacy 5.5.3
iQCVAwUBNhBQlKPbvUVI86rNAQF+cwP8D8yLB0QmESE2wdVEKw6bUYL46owjaYJt
LOZHLtpo3JZNzZcLSgLmuson2kDCaYFWOv4aFnlCnISs6QwhMnjlyK5LSqp+cI2p
Mgdmp8ZXm/0IWV7VIa1uGzlpLiLcRqEfgyKNMnRquiB6QSfgQJAVOglqPmxyowCs
c7hNwylXCtA=
=ksfc
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
--
-- Paul Gettle, #970 of 1000 (RunnerPaul@*****.com)
PGP Fingerprint, Key ID:0x48F3AACD (RSA 1024, created 98/06/26)
C260 94B3 6722 6A25 63F8 0690 9EA2 3344