From: | shadowtk@*********.com (Paul J. Adam) |
---|---|
Subject: | Discussion and Aftermath |
Date: | Sat Jan 19 05:05:01 2002 |
>>>>>[I thought you might appreciate this, just so you know where you
stand.
+++++begin transcript
D: David J H Coppinger
G: Representative Gowne
G: Thank you for meeting me so quickly, David.
D: It's not as if I'm busy these days.
G: Not officially, anyway. But I have to say, I was very impressed with
your manoeuvre.
D: Hopefully *just* impressed...
G: Pleased, too, that you at least honoured the spirit of my intention.
And just a little bit annoyed at the end result.
D: You had left us very little room to work in, Representative, and your
own choice of actions forced the outcome. Believe me, Jason is no
happier about it than you are.
G: Oh, I'm actually glad about the final outcome.
D: Really?
G: It galls me to have to punish soldiers like Lynch. I know that may
seem hard to believe, but it's true. Yet if we declare that the law
can be waived, or ignored, or glossed over, when we judge it
convenient...
I sometimes imagine a great dam, David, holding back a vast press of
water. And while it might be tempting to bore a few, tiny holes, to
let just a trickle of water through - when you do so, the torrent
follows, destroying the dam and wreaking havoc on all below. The law
has to be applied to all, and the test is how we honour it even when
we would prefer not to.
D: You'd get on well with Drake.
G: I do, as a matter of fact. I was surprised by his defence of Lynch.
Perhaps that was part of why I'm adequately content with the final
result. Everyone got what they wanted, and the law was upheld.
D: Except Lynch.
G: Oh, come on, you can't tell me he isn't pleased-
D: No, he most certainly is not. Don't assume that, because many of
the officers you meet in this town lust after power and promotion,
that Jason does. And remember that Ernang forced his promotions
through to *hurt* and *weaken* the Lynches, not to reward them.
G: He doesn't have to accept it-
D: He had no choice, any more than you did. And if he quits now he's
a civilian, and either someone else will have to fill his role, or
it will go unfilled.
G: Am I meant to feel bad about this?
D: No. Lynch will do the job he's been given, and I hope he'll do it
well. You enforce civilian control of the military, and make it clear
that the law is paramount. It's a good outcome, and I'm sure Lynch
will find ways to make his position tolerable.
G: Under proper oversight, of course.
D: Which brings me to my other issue. Representative Menges is stepping
down very shortly.
G: I heard. His wife's very ill, isn't she?
D: Yes. She's expected to recover, but the therapy is going to be slow
and unpleasant for her. Louis is taking a sabbatical to care for her.
That leaves a vacant seat on the Oversight Committee.
G: After all this, you're offering *me* a seat?
D: If you'd been involved earlier in cleaning up Ernang, we might have
been able to observe more of the legalities. Also, you're honest
and trusted, if not liked; and you understand the difference between
the way the world should be, and the way it actually is.
G: I'll need to think it over carefully.
D: Of course. I thought I should let you know in person, before you were
formally invited.
G: ...And what's your role in all this, David? You don't have a formal
post.
D: Or any ability to act by myself. I'm an adviser and counsellor,
perhaps, able to inform and guide others but powerless myself.
G: You? Powerless? I doubt it. Still, thank you for your time and your
honesty.
D: You're welcome.
+++++end transcript
I hope I did your feelings justice.]<<<<<
-- David J H Coppinger <10:06:42/01-19-63>